Showing posts with label RWCQ. Show all posts
Showing posts with label RWCQ. Show all posts

Sunday, 24 June 2018

Corruption and chaos: A new chapter in Kenyan rugby looks an awful lot like the old one

At the turn of the year Kenyan rugby was riding relatively high, in what looked to be a new chapter for Kenyan rugby. It had a blockbuster 120m Kenyan shilling sponsorship deal with betting firm Sportpesa (~£900,000, £1 = 133KES, but a tad over £2m when purchasing power parity is factored in), the Simbas (their XV senior side) had finished second in the African Gold Cup from two years running in 2016 & 2017, their best placings since 2013, leaving them in line for a Repechage spot in the 2018 edition, should they repeat their performances. In addition their 7s side was well on their way to achieve a strong 8th, and their record point haul in the world series (104, 19 points off 4th, 28 from 9th).



Since then however things have gone extremely pear shaped.

The first sign of trouble was on 2nd of January when Sportpesa announced that they were withdrawing all 600m of domestic sports sponsorship over the Government proposing to increase the rate of tax on the gross profits of gambling firms from 7.5% to 35%. Sportpesa was the main sponsor of both the Kenyan Rugby Union (KRU) and some local teams (such as the formerly Sportpesa Harlequins). There was some hope that one side would blink and that Sportpesa would reinstate their sponsorships, but when Sportpesa re-entered the sports sponsorship world they announced that it was purely football, and that they would not return to rugby. Immediately the KRU had to scramble for funds, and secured a shirt sponsorship deal with Brand Kenya (an arm of the Government) in late May for a 20m KS (£150,000) one-year deal. Although much less than they needed to run full operations, it was enough to tide the KRU over. Everything could return to normal now, right?


Wrong. For any eagle-eyed viewers watching the Paris 7s leg of the World Series you would have seen the Kenyan team were wearing a shirt with red duck tape over the 'Make It Kenya' logo (see the slightly lighter red box on Collins Injera, above). It has emerged that this was due to the KRU not paying the players their allowances for previous tournaments. Brand Kenya were furious about this and axed their deal with the KRU with immediate effect, and made a statement that indicated that they would not fund KRU again. To further complicate things Innocent Simiyu, Kenyan 7s coach, stormed the tribunal between Brand Kenya and the KRU and took responsibility for covering the sponsor, for the KRU was arguing that the players did not deserve any of the payments due to them (despite the KRU already receiving the payments from Brand Kenya). Consequently he was fired with immediate effect, even though the 7s World Cup in San Francisco was only a month away. In solidarity with Simiyu all the players are currently boycotting training, and have refused to play under the newly appointed Head Coach William Webster. The players also released a statement that said that it was a completely collective decision, and that no one person orchestrated it, in an attempt to get Simiyu reinstated.

In addition, the Simbas have just scraped a lucky away win vs Morocco (see footnote) 24-28 in the Gold Cup, and based on that performance may not end up as Africa's representative in the repechage (notably they looked significantly too weak in the pack). The KRU has also threatened to pull it's 7s team out of the 7s World Cup, and from the African Gold Cup, should they not find some more funding.

All is not completely lost however, the Kenyan Parliament MP in charge of Sports, Culture, & Tourism has offered to step in and mediate the dispute, with a view to making sure that Kenya can field their most competitive side in the 7s RWC. Immediate concerns over withdrawal from the Gold Cup have been allayed with Tusker Breweries taking over as main shirt sponsor of the XV side, in a deal worth 53mKS (~£400,000). In addition the players seem to be moving to form a union and to remove some allegedly massively corrupt members of the KRU, who have allegedly embezzled most of the previous sponsorship deals, from rugby governance. Should they do that, it'll be yet another 'new chapter' in Kenyan rugby.

I'll make sure to keep Beyond The Cartel updated with new information as it emerges, for this is quite a rapidly developing situation. To get updates as soon as I have them follow @BTCBlurandski on twitter.

Footnote: It has also emerged that the Moroccan Rugby Union is in trouble, with their Government refusing to validate the MRU's audit due to unpaid payments. It's not the only Moroccan sport in that position, but either way is not good news. Between this and the Rugby Europe debacle sometimes T2&3 rugby makes you want to cry.

Tuesday, 19 June 2018

Weekly wrap-up, week ending: 18/06/18

Hi all, I hope that this will function as a quick round-up for all of the slightly less covered rugby events of the week, of which there has been an awful lot.

Germany beats Portugal to win a two-legged tie vs Samoa

After the Rugby Europe eligibility debacle Russia was declared Europe 1, and Germany was to play the Rugby Europe Trophy winner (Portugal) for the privilege of being Europe 2. In what can only be described as a pretty dire match Germany won 16-13 (full match here). Truth be told the difference was probably made by Germany having their Wild Rugby Academy players back, while Portugal was in disarray due to not having many foreign players available and two of their leading clubs relegated to the third tier due to a mass brawl, which lead to the players from that club going on strike. I would recommend putting this a few videos below watching paint dry on your youtube playlist.


African Qualification for the Rugby World Cup kicks off

This weekend saw the beginning of the Africa Gold Cup (the Three Quarters podcast did an excellent preview). This year it consists of Namibia (24 in WR rankings), Kenya (28), Uganda (37), Tunisia (42), Zimbabwe (44), and newly promoted Morocco (38). With regards to RWC qualification, first place gains an automatic berth in Pool B against New Zealand, South Africa, Italy, and the Repechage winner. Second place wins a berth in the round-robin repechage in the autumn.

The first game of the round were Namibia hosting Uganda, which was a comprehensive victory for Namibia 55-6. Nothing overly special went on in the match, but a replay of both games is available here, should you want to see it. The second game was a 23-23 draw as Zimbabwe hosted Morocco, it was fairly entertaining, but should either side get through to the Repechage you can't imagine that they'd trouble Canada (although give the next item...)

Namibia is in the driving seat with five table points. Zimbabwe and Morocco possess two points apiece.

Canada Crush(ed)




I'm really not sure what to say here. The formerly premier T2 nation just got utterly humiliated at home by Russia, in front of 6,000 paying victims. The final score was 20-43, and Canada were utterly outplayed in every aspect, even when the Russians were down men in the bin. Full replay here. While Canada had a few full-time pros 'injured' (people have cast doubt on the authenticity of their absences), but considering that this summer series was meant to be a warmup for Canada's repechage challenge in the autumn, it has not gone well, Personally I reckon that if it consists of Germany (29th in the world), Canada (22), Kenya (28), and Hong Kong (21) then it could be a really close-run affair.

With every cloud comes a silver lining

The silver lining the the embarrassment of a summer series came in the form of Canada U20s completing an aggregate win over the USA U20s 82-62 over the two tests. This will be the third time in five years that Canada participates in the U20 Trophy (due to be hosted in Romania this year with Samoa, Romania, Canada, Uruguay, Portugal, Fiji, Namibia, and Hong Kong playing). The bad news however is that over time their performance in the competition has got worse, with their 6-10 year average position (15.8) being 1.4 places better than their 1-5 year average (17.2).


Canada has really struggled to convert top 20 finishes at youth level into senior performance, fingers crossed that Vancouver and Ontario MLR franchises come to fruition.

Czech Republic v NZ

In the latest of several high profile matches in Czechia (the last being Czech Republic v the Barbarians last November), the Czech Republic national team and U20 team played a New Zealand Ambassadors XV (assembled of New Zealand players based in Europe) in the now annual match. The U20 team got slaughtered 108-0 (at least Canada didn't have the worst loss of the week), but the senior team won 23-15. The crowd was reportedly in the region of 6,000. This is the fourth consecutive year that the event has been held, and the crowd is growing year on year.


Brief news:

Rugby Americas North Championship: Trinidad & Tobago beat the USA South 34-33, after USAS(?) led 27-12 at half time. There was some doubt whether T&T would have the funding to participate, but it looks like the money will be released imminently. [Correction 20/6/18: T&T has pulled out of the RAN Championship following funding not being released.]



MLR: NOLA edged Utah 43-46 to finish their season, but it was not enough to secure a playoff place. Glendale smashed Seattle 33-11 to confirm 1st seed, with Seattle 2nd seed. SD won perhaps the most important game, in front of 3000 fans, 31-17 against Austin to guarantee themselves 3rd or 4th seed. The regular season wraps up next week with Utah v Houston, and SD v Glendale.

Coverage not included: 

1. The USA beat it's first T1 nation in the form of a weakened Scotland in front of around 11,000 fans in Houston. The full match is available here (geoblocked to the UK), and 10 minute highlights are available here. Martin Pengelly did an excellent write-up of what this means in the Guardian.

2. The WR U20s Championship concluded with France beating England before a sellout of around 20,000. 7 minute highlights are here. From a Beyond The Cartel perspective Georgia achieved their best ever placing of 9th, and will return for a fourth consecutive appearance next year. Had they scored one more try versus South Africa they would have finished in the top four. A bright future lies ahead.

3. England lost again against the not-too-long-ago T2 nation South Africa. Why do I put myself through this? Answers on a postcard please.

Annual Report Card: Poland, 2017-18

Annual Report Card: Poland, 2017-18 It's the end of the rugby season for Poland (mostly), so I'm going to write the first in ...